Milwaukee vs DeWalt Drill: Which One Should You Buy in 2026?
Target Keyword: milwaukee vs dewalt drill
Models: Milwaukee 2904-20 vs DeWalt DCD999B
Last Updated: 2026-02-01
⚡ The Quick Verdict (For You Impatient Types)
| What Matters | Winner | Milwaukee 2904-20 | DeWalt DCD999B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 🏆 Milwaukee | ⭐ 4.8/5 (6,750+) | ⭐ 4.8/5 (6,300+) |
| Raw Power | DeWalt | 1,400 in-lbs | 1,219 UWO (w/ FlexVolt) |
| Compact Size | 🏆 Milwaukee | 6.9″ length | 8.4″ length |
| Value | 🏆 Milwaukee | $199, 5-yr warranty | $239, 3-yr warranty |
| Concrete Work | 🏆 DeWalt | 33,000 BPM | 38,250 BPM |
| Safety | 🏆 Milwaukee | ✅ AutoStop | ❌ No kickback control |
| View Deal → | — | View Deal | View Deal |
TL;DR: The Milwaukee 2904-20 wins for most DIYers. It’s smaller, lighter, cheaper, has a longer warranty, and performs consistently across every test category. The DeWalt DCD999B is the power king — but only if you’re willing to buy expensive FlexVolt batteries to unlock its potential.
> 💰 Budget Reality Check: Both drills hover around $200-300. That’s premium territory for weekend warriors — but these are “buy it for life” tools that’ll outlast a dozen cheap drills. If you’re building one deck, refinishing the basement, AND assembling furniture for the next 15 years, the math works out.
The Contenders: What We’re Comparing
Let’s be clear about what we’re testing here. These are the flagship 1/2″ hammer drill/drivers from each brand — the serious options that weekend warriors reach for when they’re tired of underpowered bargain-bin drills dying mid-project.
Milwaukee M18 FUEL 1/2″ Hammer Drill (2904-20) — Fourth generation of Milwaukee’s flagship. Brushless, compact, and packed with their POWERSTATE motor tech.
DeWalt 20V MAX FlexVolt Advantage Hammer Drill (DCD999B) — DeWalt’s answer to the power wars. The “FlexVolt Advantage” means it can draw extra juice from their bigger batteries.
These are tools that’ll handle your deck rebuild, bathroom remodel, and every IKEA disaster in between — without breaking a sweat. Let’s see which one earns a spot in your garage.
Milwaukee 2904-20 vs DeWalt DCD999B: Full Specs Comparison
Here’s where things get nerdy. Feel free to skip if numbers make your eyes glaze over — I’ll translate what actually matters below.
| Spec | Milwaukee 2904-20 🏆 | DeWalt DCD999B 🏆 |
|---|---|---|
| Peak Torque | 1,400 in-lbs | 1,219 UWO* |
| Tested Soft Torque | 539 in-lbs (591 w/ HO battery) | 468 in-lbs |
| Max RPM | 2,100 | 2,000 (2,250 in hammer mode) |
| Speed Settings | 2 | 3 |
| Max BPM (Hammer) | 33,000 | 38,250 |
| Chuck | 1/2″ all-metal, carbide teeth | 1/2″ all-metal ratcheting |
| Length | 6.9″ 🏆 | 8.4″ |
| Weight (bare tool) | 3.3 lbs 🏆 | 3.6 lbs |
| Weight (with 5Ah) | 4.9 lbs 🏆 | 5.0 lbs |
| Brushless | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Kickback Control | ✅ AutoStop 🏆 | ❌ No |
| Warranty | 5 years 🏆 | 3 years |
| Price (bare tool) | $199 🏆💰 | $239 |
| Torque per Dollar | 7.04 in-lbs/$ 🏆💰 | 5.10 UWO/$ |
| Amazon Rating | ⭐ 4.8/5 (6,750+) | ⭐ 4.8/5 (6,300+) |
| View Deal → | View Deal | View Deal |
*DeWalt uses UWO (Unit Watts Out) instead of in-lbs, which is basically a marketing trick to make apples-to-oranges comparisons harder. Classic DeWalt.
🏆 = Category Winner | 💰 = Better Value
What Real Users Are Saying: Aggregated Ratings
I pulled ratings from major retailers because I don’t trust any single source (and neither should you). Over 13,000 buyers weighed in — here’s what they said:
| Source | Milwaukee 2904-20 | DeWalt DCD999B |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon | ⭐ 4.8/5 (6,750+ reviews) | ⭐ 4.8/5 (6,300+ reviews) |
| Home Depot | ⭐ 4.7/5 (2,500+ reviews) | ⭐ 4.8/5 (2,100+ reviews) |
| Combined Average | 4.75/5 🏆 | 4.80/5 🏆 |
| Total Reviews | 9,250+ | 8,400+ |
| Expert Rating | 🏆 “Best Overall Cordless Drill” | “Top-tier with FlexVolt” |
| View Deal → | View Deal | View Deal |
Both drills are highly rated — thousands of buyers agree these are solid picks. The difference is in the nuance of those reviews — Milwaukee gets praised for all-around excellence, while DeWalt reviews often mention needing FlexVolt batteries to get the advertised performance.
💰 Best Value Calculator: True Cost of Ownership
What you actually pay for the performance you get:
Bare Tool Comparison
| Metric | Milwaukee 2904-20 | DeWalt DCD999B | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $199 | $239 | 🏆 Milwaukee (-$40) |
| Torque Output | 1,400 in-lbs | 1,219 UWO | 🏆 Milwaukee |
| Torque per Dollar | 7.04 in-lbs/$ | 5.10 UWO/$ | 🏆 Milwaukee (+38%) |
| Warranty | 5 years | 3 years | 🏆 Milwaukee (+2 years) |
| Kickback Protection | ✅ AutoStop | ❌ None | 🏆 Milwaukee |
Hidden Cost Reality Check ⚠️
| Cost Factor | Milwaukee 2904-20 | DeWalt DCD999B |
|---|---|---|
| Bare Tool | $199 | $239 |
| Battery Needed | Any M18 5.0Ah (~$100) | FlexVolt 6.0Ah (~$150)* |
| Total Entry Cost | ~$299 | ~$389 |
| Battery Ecosystem | 200+ M18 tools | FlexVolt + 20V MAX compatible |
*DeWalt DCD999B requires FlexVolt batteries to unlock full power potential. With standard 20V batteries, performance is comparable to drills costing $100 less.
5-Year Cost of Ownership
| Scenario | Milwaukee 2904-20 | DeWalt DCD999B |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Purchase | $299 (kit with battery) | $389 (bare tool + FlexVolt) |
| Replacement Battery | $100 (after warranty) | $150 |
| Extended Warranty | Included 5 years | $89 (2 extra years) |
| 5-Year Total | ~$400 | ~$630 |
💰 Bottom Line: Milwaukee wins on value by $230+ over 5 years — that’s enough to buy a matching impact driver or circular saw in the same ecosystem.
Feature Showdown: What Actually Matters
Head-to-Head: Category Breakdown
⚡ Power: Does More Muscle Matter?
On paper: DeWalt’s DCD999B claims 1,219 UWO, but that number needs context. With a standard 5Ah battery, it’s… fine. With a FlexVolt battery? It transforms into an absolute monster.
In testing: Here’s what Pro Tool Reviews found:
| Test | Milwaukee (5.0Ah) | DeWalt (6.0Ah FlexVolt) |
|---|---|---|
| 1″ Spade Bit | 3.4 sec | 2.7 sec |
| 2-9/16″ Self-Feed | 2.6 sec | 2.3 sec |
| 3/8″ Concrete | 3.7 sec | 2.9 sec |
| Soft Torque | 539 in-lbs | 468 in-lbs |
The DeWalt is faster in raw drilling tests when using FlexVolt. But here’s the kicker: Milwaukee’s soft torque (the actual turning force you feel) is consistently higher. That matters when you’re driving lag bolts into your deck frame or sinking structural screws into a headboard build.
Winner: Draw. DeWalt wins drilling speed with FlexVolt; Milwaukee wins consistent torque.
📐 Ergonomics & Size
This is where Milwaukee pulls ahead — significantly.
Milwaukee 2904-20: 6.9″ long, 3.3 lbs bare
DeWalt DCD999B: 8.4″ long, 3.6 lbs bare
That 1.5″ difference sounds small until you’re trying to drill between studs in the bathroom wall, work inside a kitchen cabinet, or squeeze behind the toilet to mount that new TP holder. The Milwaukee fits where the DeWalt won’t.
The weight difference is marginal (0.3 lbs), but Milwaukee’s balance with its smaller form factor makes it feel lighter during a Saturday afternoon project marathon.
Winner: Milwaukee, decisively.
🔧 Features That Actually Matter
Milwaukee’s killer feature: AutoStop Control Mode
This is kickback protection — if the drill binds up on you (say, an auger bit catches in hard wood), it cuts power before your wrist does a 180. If you’ve ever had a drill try to twist out of your hands while you’re up on a ladder, you know why this matters. DeWalt doesn’t have this.
DeWalt’s answer: 3-Speed Transmission
The DCD999B has three speed settings vs Milwaukee’s two. That extra middle gear gives you more flexibility… in theory. Honestly, most weekend warriors never touch it — you’ll live on high speed and low speed.
Other features:
| Feature | Milwaukee | DeWalt |
|---|---|---|
| LED Light | ✅ Standard | ✅ With foot controls |
| Smart Tool Tech | One-Key ($249 version) | Tool Connect ready |
| Belt Clip | ✅ All-metal | ✅ Standard |
| Side Handle | ✅ Included | ✅ Included |
Winner: Milwaukee. AutoStop alone puts it over the top — preventing injury beats extra speed settings.
🛡️ Warranty & Long-Term Reliability
Milwaukee: 5-year limited warranty
DeWalt: 3-year limited warranty
Two extra years of coverage is a significant difference, especially for tools that might sit in your garage for months between projects. Both brands have decent service networks, but Milwaukee’s longer warranty shows confidence in their build quality.
From real-world feedback: both drills hold up well. Milwaukee’s all-metal construction gets particular praise for durability — even when dropped off ladders (not that we recommend testing this). For more recommendations, check out our best cordless drills overall guide.
Winner: Milwaukee. More coverage, same quality.
💰 Value: What You Actually Pay
Let’s talk money — because you’re not running a business expense account for your deck project.
| Configuration | Milwaukee 2904-20 | DeWalt DCD999B | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bare Tool | $199 | $239 | 🏆 $40 |
| Kit with Batteries | $299 (2x 5.0Ah) | $329 (1x 6.0Ah FlexVolt) | 🏆 $30 + extra battery |
| Combo w/ Impact Driver | $379 | $329-399 | Comparable |
| 5-Year Ownership | ~$400 | ~$630 | 🏆 $230 |
| View Deal → | |
|---|---|
| 👉 Milwaukee 2904-20 | 👉 DeWalt DCD999B |
The Milwaukee is $40 cheaper as a bare tool. The kit deal is even better — you get two batteries for $299 vs DeWalt’s single (expensive) FlexVolt battery for $329.
And here’s the hidden cost of DeWalt’s “FlexVolt Advantage”: the drill basically requires FlexVolt batteries to perform at its peak. Those batteries run $150-200 each. Your $239 drill just became a $400+ investment.
Milwaukee performs excellently with standard M18 batteries. No upcharge required.
Winner: 🏆 Milwaukee. Better upfront price, no battery tax, longer warranty. You might also find our best drills under $100 roundup helpful.
The Verdict: Milwaukee 2904-20 Wins 🏆
Let me be direct: the Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2904-20 is the better drill for most DIYers.
It’s not because it won every single test. It didn’t — DeWalt’s concrete drilling speed with FlexVolt is genuinely impressive. Milwaukee wins because:
1. Consistent excellence — Pro Tool Reviews named it their #1 overall cordless drill because it placed top 3-5 in every category. That matters more than winning one benchmark.
2. Smaller and lighter — 1.5″ shorter makes a real difference when you’re working in closets, under sinks, or anywhere your house throws tight spots at you.
3. AutoStop saves wrists — Kickback control isn’t a gimmick. It’s injury prevention — especially valuable if you’re working solo without a second pair of hands.
4. Better value — $40 cheaper, longer warranty, and no expensive battery requirement. Your wallet will thank you.
5. No hidden costs — Works great with standard batteries. DeWalt needs FlexVolt to shine.
The DeWalt DCD999B is an excellent drill — I’m not dunking on it. With FlexVolt batteries, it’s a powerhouse for concrete and masonry. But that power comes with weight, length, and cost tradeoffs that most weekend warriors don’t need.
👉 [Get the Milwaukee 2904-20][https://www.homedepot.com/p/Milwaukee-M18-FUEL-18V-Lithium-Ion-Brushless-Cordless-1-2-in-Hammer-Drill-Driver-Tool-Only-2904-20/320326855]
Who Should Buy the Milwaukee 2904-20
Perfect for the weekend warrior who wants one drill to rule them all.
Choose Milwaukee if you:
- ✅ Want a do-everything drill for deck builds, furniture projects, and home repairs
- ✅ Work in tight spaces (bathroom remodels, closet shelving, under-cabinet repairs)
- ✅ Use your drill a couple times a month and want it to just work every time
- ✅ Value your wrist (AutoStop kickback control is no joke when you’re alone on a ladder)
- ✅ Want 5-year warranty peace of mind for a tool you’ll own for a decade
- ✅ Don’t want to buy expensive batteries to unlock performance
- ✅ Are starting a tool collection and want a brand you can grow with
Best way to buy: The Milwaukee 2904-22 kit ($299) with two 5.0Ah batteries is the sweet spot — those batteries work with Milwaukee’s whole M18 lineup, from circular saws to sanders. Or grab the 3697-22 combo ($379) if you also need an impact driver (spoiler: you do).
| Configuration | Price | View Deal → |
|---|---|---|
| Bare Tool | $199 | 👉 Buy Now |
| Kit (2x 5.0Ah) | $299 | 👉 Buy Now |
| Combo w/ Impact | $379 | 👉 Buy Now |
Who Should Buy the DeWalt DCD999B
For the DIYer who already owns yellow tools — or plans to bust a lot of concrete.
Choose DeWalt if you:
- ✅ Already own FlexVolt batteries (critical — don’t buy this without them)
- ✅ Have concrete projects planned (anchoring a pergola, mounting to basement walls)
- ✅ Prefer 3-speed transmission control for precision work
- ✅ Want Tool Connect for keeping track of your tools
- ✅ Are already locked into the DeWalt ecosystem and happy there
Honest caveat: If you’re starting fresh and don’t own either platform, Milwaukee is the smarter buy. The DeWalt is for people already invested in FlexVolt who want to maximize their existing batteries. Otherwise, you’re paying a premium for power you might not need.
| Configuration | Price | View Deal → |
|---|---|---|
| Bare Tool | $239 | 👉 Buy Now |
| Kit w/ FlexVolt | $329 | 👉 Buy Now |
| Combo w/ Impact | $399 | 👉 Buy Now |
🔧 Beyond Drills: Impact Drivers Head-to-Head
If you’re only comparing drills, you’re missing half the story. Impact drivers are where most DIYers spend their time — deck screws, cabinet assembly, furniture builds. Let’s see how Milwaukee and DeWalt stack up.
The Contenders: Milwaukee 2953-20 vs DeWalt DCF860
| Spec | Milwaukee 2953-20 | DeWalt DCF860 |
|---|---|---|
| Max Torque | 2,000 in-lbs | 2,500 in-lbs 🏆 |
| IPM (Impacts Per Minute) | 0–1,200/2,900/4,400 | 0–1,600/3,200/3,800 |
| Control Modes | 4 modes 🏆 | 3 speeds |
| Price (Bare Tool) | $179 | $179 |
| Length | 5.1″ 🏆 | 5.3″ |
| Weight | 2.8 lbs | 2.75 lbs |
The verdict: DeWalt wins on paper with 500 more in-lbs of torque, but Milwaukee’s four-mode drive control gives you more precision. Milwaukee’s self-tapping screw mode is a game-changer for metal roofing and framing, while the precision mode excels at cabinet hardware installation.
Real-world testing from Pro Tool Reviews shows the Milwaukee maintains higher sustained torque under continuous load despite lower peak specs — meaning less power drop-off when you’re driving 200 deck screws in a row.
Winner: Draw. DeWalt for raw power, Milwaukee for control and sustained performance.
🪚 Circular Saws: Cut Performance Comparison
Circular saws are the backbone of any deck build or remodel. Here’s how Milwaukee and DeWalt’s flagship cordless models compare.
Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2834 vs DeWalt 20V Max XR DCS590
| Spec | Milwaukee 2834 | DeWalt DCS590 |
|---|---|---|
| Motor RPM | 5,800 RPM 🏆 | 5,500 RPM |
| Max Power Output | 15A equivalent | 1,700 MWO |
| Blade Size | 7-1/4″ | 7-1/4″ |
| Bevel Capacity | 0-50° (positive stops) | 0-57° |
| Price (Bare Tool) | $279 | $249 🏆💰 |
| Blade Change | Tool-free 🏆 | Wrench required |
| Weight | 9.0 lbs | 8.8 lbs |
The verdict: Milwaukee’s 2834 edges ahead with 300 more RPM and easier blade changes, but DeWalt’s DCS590 is $30 cheaper and cuts just as well in real-world use. Pro Tool Reviews testing showed both saws completing identical cuts within seconds of each other.
Milwaukee’s tool-free blade change and positive bevel stops make it more user-friendly for professionals who swap blades frequently. DeWalt’s deeper bevel capacity (57° vs 50°) is useful if you do a lot of compound miter cuts. For more recommendations, check our best circular saws guide.
Winner: Milwaukee for features, DeWalt for value.
🔋 Battery Ecosystem: M18 vs 20V Max Platform
Here’s where brand loyalty gets expensive — or saves you money long-term. Let’s break down the real differences between Milwaukee’s M18 and DeWalt’s 20V Max battery platforms.
Voltage: Marketing vs Reality
First, let’s clear up the confusion: M18 and 20V Max are the same voltage. Milwaukee uses the nominal 18V rating, DeWalt uses the maximum 20V rating. Both systems operate at the same voltage under load. Don’t let the numbers fool you — this is pure marketing.
Battery Capacity Options
| Platform | Capacity Range | Flagship Battery | Cost (Flagship) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee M18 | 2.0Ah – 12.0Ah | 12.0Ah High Output | ~$249 |
| DeWalt 20V Max | 1.3Ah – 15.0Ah | 15.0Ah PowerStack 🏆 | ~$279 |
DeWalt wins on maximum capacity with their massive 15.0Ah battery, but here’s the catch: most DIYers will never need that much juice. A 5.0Ah battery will handle 99% of weekend warrior projects.
Runtime & Power Delivery
According to independent testing from Pro Tool Reviews:
- Milwaukee High Output batteries deliver superior power under heavy load — better for high-drain tools like circular saws and grinders
- DeWalt 20V Max batteries excel in runtime efficiency for standard-demand tasks — better for all-day drilling and driving
The bottom line: Milwaukee’s batteries hit harder during peak demand, DeWalt’s last longer during steady use. For burst performance (cutting, grinding), Milwaukee. For marathon sessions (assembly, installation), DeWalt.
Tool Ecosystem Size
| Platform | Total Tools Available | Specialty Tools |
|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee M18 | 200+ 🏆 | HVAC, plumbing, electrical |
| DeWalt 20V Max | 185+ | Woodworking, construction |
Milwaukee edges ahead with over 200 M18 tools, including specialized trade equipment (pipe cutters, inspection cameras, HVAC tools). DeWalt’s lineup is heavily weighted toward construction and woodworking.
Winner: Milwaukee for tool variety, DeWalt for max capacity. Both ecosystems will serve DIYers well.
🛡️ Warranty & Support: Long-Term Value
Tools break. Batteries die. Here’s what you’re actually covered for.
| Coverage | Milwaukee | DeWalt |
|---|---|---|
| Tool Warranty | 5 years 🏆 | 3 years |
| Battery Warranty | 3 years | 3 years 🏆 |
| Service Centers | 600+ locations (US) | 800+ locations (US) |
| Warranty Registration | Optional (recommended) | Optional (recommended) |
Milwaukee’s 5-year tool warranty is a significant advantage — 2 extra years of coverage adds real value for tools you’ll own for a decade or more. Both brands have extensive service networks, so getting repairs isn’t a hassle.
Battery warranties are identical at 3 years, but here’s the reality: most lithium-ion batteries degrade after 300-500 charge cycles regardless of warranty. If you’re using your tools weekly, expect to buy replacement batteries every 3-4 years.
Winner: Milwaukee, thanks to the longer tool warranty.
💰 Platform Value Analysis: 5-Year Total Cost
Let’s do the math on what it actually costs to build a Milwaukee or DeWalt tool collection over 5 years. This is where smart buying pays off.
Starter Kit Comparison
| Kit Contents | Milwaukee M18 | DeWalt 20V Max |
|---|---|---|
| Drill + Impact Driver Combo | $379 (2x 5.0Ah) | $329 (2x 4.0Ah) |
| Circular Saw (bare) | $279 | $249 |
| Reciprocating Saw (bare) | $179 | $169 |
| Total Initial Investment | $837 | $747 🏆💰 |
DeWalt is $90 cheaper upfront for a 4-tool starter kit. That’s meaningful if you’re buying everything at once.
5-Year Expansion Costs
But here’s where the math gets interesting. Most DIYers add 2-3 tools per year as projects arise.
| Year 1-5 Additions | Milwaukee M18 | DeWalt 20V Max |
|---|---|---|
| Angle Grinder (bare) | $199 | $179 |
| Oscillating Tool (bare) | $149 | $139 |
| Shop Vac (bare) | $99 | $99 |
| Replacement Batteries (2x) | $200 (5.0Ah) | $220 (6.0Ah FlexVolt) |
| 5-Year Total | ~$1,484 | ~$1,384 🏆💰 |
DeWalt saves you ~$100 over 5 years — but that assumes comparable battery performance. If you need FlexVolt batteries to get peak performance from DeWalt’s top-tier tools (like the drill we tested), that cost advantage disappears quickly.
The Milwaukee Premium: Is It Worth It?
Milwaukee costs 7-10% more on average across comparable tools. You’re paying for:
- ✅ 5-year vs 3-year warranty (2 extra years of coverage)
- ✅ More compact tool designs (easier to work in tight spaces)
- ✅ Safety features like AutoStop kickback control
- ✅ Larger tool ecosystem (200+ vs 185 tools)
If you value any of those features, the premium is justified. If you’re purely budget-focused, DeWalt delivers 95% of the performance for less money.
Winner: DeWalt for pure cost savings, Milwaukee for value-per-dollar when you factor in warranty and features.
🔧 Beyond Drills: Impact Drivers Head-to-Head
If you’re only comparing drills, you’re missing half the story. Impact drivers are where most DIYers spend their time — deck screws, cabinet assembly, furniture builds. Let’s see how Milwaukee and DeWalt stack up.
The Contenders: Milwaukee 2953-20 vs DeWalt DCF860
| Spec | Milwaukee 2953-20 | DeWalt DCF860 |
|---|---|---|
| Max Torque | 2,000 in-lbs | 2,500 in-lbs 🏆 |
| IPM (Impacts Per Minute) | 0–1,200/2,900/4,400 | 0–1,600/3,200/3,800 |
| Control Modes | 4 modes 🏆 | 3 speeds |
| Price (Bare Tool) | $179 | $179 |
| Length | 5.1″ 🏆 | 5.3″ |
| Weight | 2.8 lbs | 2.75 lbs |
The verdict: DeWalt wins on paper with 500 more in-lbs of torque, but Milwaukee’s four-mode drive control gives you more precision. Milwaukee’s self-tapping screw mode is a game-changer for metal roofing and framing, while the precision mode excels at cabinet hardware installation.
Real-world testing from Pro Tool Reviews shows the Milwaukee maintains higher sustained torque under continuous load despite lower peak specs — meaning less power drop-off when you’re driving 200 deck screws in a row.
Winner: Draw. DeWalt for raw power, Milwaukee for control and sustained performance.
🪚 Circular Saws: Cut Performance Comparison
Circular saws are the backbone of any deck build or remodel. Here’s how Milwaukee and DeWalt’s flagship cordless models compare.
Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2834 vs DeWalt 20V Max XR DCS590
| Spec | Milwaukee 2834 | DeWalt DCS590 |
|---|---|---|
| Motor RPM | 5,800 RPM 🏆 | 5,500 RPM |
| Max Power Output | 15A equivalent | 1,700 MWO |
| Blade Size | 7-1/4″ | 7-1/4″ |
| Bevel Capacity | 0-50° (positive stops) | 0-57° |
| Price (Bare Tool) | $279 | $249 🏆💰 |
| Blade Change | Tool-free 🏆 | Wrench required |
| Weight | 9.0 lbs | 8.8 lbs |
The verdict: Milwaukee’s 2834 edges ahead with 300 more RPM and easier blade changes, but DeWalt’s DCS590 is $30 cheaper and cuts just as well in real-world use. Pro Tool Reviews testing showed both saws completing identical cuts within seconds of each other.
Milwaukee’s tool-free blade change and positive bevel stops make it more user-friendly for professionals who swap blades frequently. DeWalt’s deeper bevel capacity (57° vs 50°) is useful if you do a lot of compound miter cuts. For more recommendations, check our best circular saws guide.
Winner: Milwaukee for features, DeWalt for value.
🔋 Battery Ecosystem: M18 vs 20V Max Platform
Here’s where brand loyalty gets expensive — or saves you money long-term. Let’s break down the real differences between Milwaukee’s M18 and DeWalt’s 20V Max battery platforms.
Voltage: Marketing vs Reality
First, let’s clear up the confusion: M18 and 20V Max are the same voltage. Milwaukee uses the nominal 18V rating, DeWalt uses the maximum 20V rating. Both systems operate at the same voltage under load. Don’t let the numbers fool you — this is pure marketing.
Battery Capacity Options
| Platform | Capacity Range | Flagship Battery | Cost (Flagship) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee M18 | 2.0Ah – 12.0Ah | 12.0Ah High Output | ~$249 |
| DeWalt 20V Max | 1.3Ah – 15.0Ah | 15.0Ah PowerStack 🏆 | ~$279 |
DeWalt wins on maximum capacity with their massive 15.0Ah battery, but here’s the catch: most DIYers will never need that much juice. A 5.0Ah battery will handle 99% of weekend warrior projects.
Runtime & Power Delivery
According to independent testing from Pro Tool Reviews:
- Milwaukee High Output batteries deliver superior power under heavy load — better for high-drain tools like circular saws and grinders
- DeWalt 20V Max batteries excel in runtime efficiency for standard-demand tasks — better for all-day drilling and driving
The bottom line: Milwaukee’s batteries hit harder during peak demand, DeWalt’s last longer during steady use. For burst performance (cutting, grinding), Milwaukee. For marathon sessions (assembly, installation), DeWalt.
Tool Ecosystem Size
| Platform | Total Tools Available | Specialty Tools |
|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee M18 | 200+ 🏆 | HVAC, plumbing, electrical |
| DeWalt 20V Max | 185+ | Woodworking, construction |
Milwaukee edges ahead with over 200 M18 tools, including specialized trade equipment (pipe cutters, inspection cameras, HVAC tools). DeWalt’s lineup is heavily weighted toward construction and woodworking.
Winner: Milwaukee for tool variety, DeWalt for max capacity. Both ecosystems will serve DIYers well.
🛡️ Warranty & Support: Long-Term Value
Tools break. Batteries die. Here’s what you’re actually covered for.
| Coverage | Milwaukee | DeWalt |
|---|---|---|
| Tool Warranty | 5 years 🏆 | 3 years |
| Battery Warranty | 3 years | 3 years 🏆 |
| Service Centers | 600+ locations (US) | 800+ locations (US) |
| Warranty Registration | Optional (recommended) | Optional (recommended) |
Milwaukee’s 5-year tool warranty is a significant advantage — 2 extra years of coverage adds real value for tools you’ll own for a decade or more. Both brands have extensive service networks, so getting repairs isn’t a hassle.
Battery warranties are identical at 3 years, but here’s the reality: most lithium-ion batteries degrade after 300-500 charge cycles regardless of warranty. If you’re using your tools weekly, expect to buy replacement batteries every 3-4 years.
Winner: Milwaukee, thanks to the longer tool warranty.
💰 Platform Value Analysis: 5-Year Total Cost
Let’s do the math on what it actually costs to build a Milwaukee or DeWalt tool collection over 5 years. This is where smart buying pays off.
Starter Kit Comparison
| Kit Contents | Milwaukee M18 | DeWalt 20V Max |
|---|---|---|
| Drill + Impact Driver Combo | $379 (2x 5.0Ah) | $329 (2x 4.0Ah) |
| Circular Saw (bare) | $279 | $249 |
| Reciprocating Saw (bare) | $179 | $169 |
| Total Initial Investment | $837 | $747 🏆💰 |
DeWalt is $90 cheaper upfront for a 4-tool starter kit. That’s meaningful if you’re buying everything at once.
5-Year Expansion Costs
But here’s where the math gets interesting. Most DIYers add 2-3 tools per year as projects arise.
| Year 1-5 Additions | Milwaukee M18 | DeWalt 20V Max |
|---|---|---|
| Angle Grinder (bare) | $199 | $179 |
| Oscillating Tool (bare) | $149 | $139 |
| Shop Vac (bare) | $99 | $99 |
| Replacement Batteries (2x) | $200 (5.0Ah) | $220 (6.0Ah FlexVolt) |
| 5-Year Total | ~$1,484 | ~$1,384 🏆💰 |
DeWalt saves you ~$100 over 5 years — but that assumes comparable battery performance. If you need FlexVolt batteries to get peak performance from DeWalt’s top-tier tools (like the drill we tested), that cost advantage disappears quickly.
The Milwaukee Premium: Is It Worth It?
Milwaukee costs 7-10% more on average across comparable tools. You’re paying for:
- ✅ 5-year vs 3-year warranty (2 extra years of coverage)
- ✅ More compact tool designs (easier to work in tight spaces)
- ✅ Safety features like AutoStop kickback control
- ✅ Larger tool ecosystem (200+ vs 185 tools)
If you value any of those features, the premium is justified. If you’re purely budget-focused, DeWalt delivers 95% of the performance for less money.
Winner: DeWalt for pure cost savings, Milwaukee for value-per-dollar when you factor in warranty and features.
🏆 Final Verdict: Which Brand Should You Choose?
After comparing drills, impact drivers, circular saws, batteries, and long-term costs, here’s the honest breakdown:
Choose Milwaukee If You:
- ✅ Want the most compact, maneuverable tools for tight spaces
- ✅ Value safety features (AutoStop kickback protection saves wrists)
- ✅ Prefer longer warranties (5 years vs 3 years)
- ✅ Need specialty trade tools (HVAC, plumbing, electrical)
- ✅ Are willing to pay 7-10% more for premium features
- ✅ Work in high-load scenarios (framing, heavy construction)
Choose DeWalt If You:
- ✅ Budget is your #1 priority (~$100 cheaper over 5 years)
- ✅ Need maximum battery runtime for all-day projects
- ✅ Already own DeWalt tools and want to stay in the ecosystem
- ✅ Focus on woodworking and construction (DeWalt’s specialty)
- ✅ Want the highest-capacity batteries available (15.0Ah PowerStack)
- ✅ Prefer wider service network availability (800+ vs 600 locations)
The Tie-Breaker Question
If you’re starting from zero and buying your first cordless platform, Milwaukee wins for most DIYers. The combination of compact size, 5-year warranty, and excellent all-around performance makes it the safer long-term bet — even if it costs slightly more upfront.
If you’re already invested in one ecosystem, stay there. The cost of switching platforms (buying all new batteries and chargers) outweighs any marginal performance gains. Both brands make excellent tools that will serve you well for years.
🔗 Ready to commit? Check out our best cordless drills and best impact drivers guides for specific model recommendations.
🏆 Final Verdict: Which Brand Should You Choose?
After comparing drills, impact drivers, circular saws, batteries, and long-term costs, here’s the honest breakdown:
Choose Milwaukee If You:
- ✅ Want the most compact, maneuverable tools for tight spaces
- ✅ Value safety features (AutoStop kickback protection saves wrists)
- ✅ Prefer longer warranties (5 years vs 3 years)
- ✅ Need specialty trade tools (HVAC, plumbing, electrical)
- ✅ Are willing to pay 7-10% more for premium features
- ✅ Work in high-load scenarios (framing, heavy construction)
Choose DeWalt If You:
- ✅ Budget is your #1 priority (~$100 cheaper over 5 years)
- ✅ Need maximum battery runtime for all-day projects
- ✅ Already own DeWalt tools and want to stay in the ecosystem
- ✅ Focus on woodworking and construction (DeWalt’s specialty)
- ✅ Want the highest-capacity batteries available (15.0Ah PowerStack)
- ✅ Prefer wider service network availability (800+ vs 600 locations)
The Tie-Breaker Question
If you’re starting from zero and buying your first cordless platform, Milwaukee wins for most DIYers. The combination of compact size, 5-year warranty, and excellent all-around performance makes it the safer long-term bet — even if it costs slightly more upfront.
If you’re already invested in one ecosystem, stay there. The cost of switching platforms (buying all new batteries and chargers) outweighs any marginal performance gains. Both brands make excellent tools that will serve you well for years.
🔗 Ready to commit? Check out our best cordless drills and best impact drivers guides for specific model recommendations.
Final Thoughts
The Milwaukee vs DeWalt drill debate will never die — and that’s fine. Both companies make excellent tools, and brand loyalty isn’t always irrational. If you inherited a garage full of yellow batteries from your dad and you’ve had happy years with DeWalt, the DCD999B won’t disappoint you.
But if you’re making a fresh decision based purely on performance, value, and practicality? The Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2904-20 is the drill I’d buy. It’s the one I’d recommend to my friends who text me “what drill should I get?” at midnight. It’s the one that’ll handle your deck, your bookshelf, your cabinet hinges, and every random home repair for the next 15 years.
Now stop overthinking it and go build something.
Have questions about the Milwaukee vs DeWalt drill comparison? Drop a comment below or hit me up on social. And if you found this helpful, sharing is caring — it helps keep the site running.
Last updated: February 2026
Power Tool Insider is reader-supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Power Tool Insider is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. This doesn’t affect our recommendations — we only recommend tools we’d actually use. Full disclosure.